IStifel
Investment Strategist
Investment Strategist
Nearing Retirement. Changing Jobs. Consider a Rollover.
Rollover Center
If you’re getting ready to retire or are simply
considering a job change, you may be wondering
what you should do with the money you’ve saved
in your employer-sponsored retirement plan. When
the time comes to make a job transition, you’ll have
several options. Each has its own pros and cons.
Cash out.
This option may sound tempting, but
it comes with a high degree of risk. While cashing
out gives you immediate access to your money, you
will not only forgo any potential tax-deferred growth
your assets could have generated, you could also
be faced with a hefty tax bill. If you cash out prior
to reaching age 59 ½, your distribution will be subject to both ordinary income taxes and a 10 percent early
withdrawal penalty (some exceptions to the 10 percent penalty may apply, most notably if you are age 55
or older at the time of termination of employment). In addition, your former employer is required to withhold
20 percent of the distribution for federal taxes, further reducing the amount you stand to receive. The 20
percent withholding (but not the 10 percent penalty) will be counted against your income tax due or toward
any refund when you file your tax return. Therefore, you may want to consider other sources before tapping
into your retirement savings, a move that could potentially sabotage your long-term plans.
Leave your money in the existing plan.
If your retirement plan balance exceeds $5,000, the plan
provider is required to allow you to keep your money in the plan after you’ve left the company. This is a
simple option, as it requires no action on your part and avoids the tax and penalties associated with taking
a payout. And due to economies of scale, your previous employer’s plan may offer such benefits as low fees
and discounts on investment-related expenses. Despite this option’s simplicity, however, its disadvantages
may outweigh its advantages.
First of all, you won’t be able to contribute any additional dollars to your old plan, and you’ll also be
limited to only the investment options available through the plan. Your former employer may make
changes to its plan that could adversely affect your account, and if the company suddenly goes out of
business or merges with a competitor, although your assets will be protected, things could become even
more complicated. Some plans even assess an annual fee to terminated participants.
Finally, it can be easy to forget about the money you’ve left in your previous employer’s retirement plan,
especially if you decide to participate in your next employer’s plan. If you’re a frequent job changer, you
could wind up with money in several different employer-sponsored plans. Under such a scenario, you
would be responsible for furnishing each plan provider with address changes and beneficiary updates
as they occur. And if your assets are spread out among several different plans, they may be invested in
vehicles that overlap with each other or contradict your overall investment strategy. By having all of your
retirement savings consolidated in one place, it is easier to ensure that all of your investments are properly
aligned with your goals.
April 2014
SNINS0314
pg_0002
Rollover to your new employer’s plan.
If
your new employer offers a retirement plan that
accepts rollovers, moving your money there also
protects you from the tax and penalties associated
with taking a payout. The ability to continue
making contributions also makes this option more
appealing than leaving your money in your previous
employer’s plan. However, this option is only as
attractive as your new employer’s plan. Does it offer
things such as full brokerage services, the ability to
take loans, competitive fees, and varied investment
options that fit your objectives. It is important to
thoroughly evaluate the options in your new employer’s plan and decide whether or not they are sufficient
to help you pursue your retirement goals and are consistent with your personal investing philosophy.
Roll your money into an IRA.
You may find a rollover into an IRA to be an attractive alternative,
as it may offer significantly more flexibility than the other options.
First of all, with an IRA, you can choose from a wide variety of investments, rather than simply the
limited number of core investment options employer-sponsored plans typically offer. And if your
retirement plan holdings are heavily weighted with shares of employer stock, an IRA rollover provides
an excellent opportunity for diversification. However, a distribution from the plan of highly appreciated
employer stock offers special tax advantages which are not available if the stock is rolled to an IRA.
The rollover may be combined with other retirement dollars as well. For example, if you have worked
at multiple jobs and have several retirement plan accounts, you can use a rollover to consolidate them
into a single IRA account. Doing so will allow you to streamline your paperwork with a single statement,
make it easier to maintain your desired investment strategy and calculate required minimum distributions,
and possibly even reduce the amount of fees you pay.
And once you’ve established a rollover IRA, you can continue making contributions to it in the future.
The 2014 contribution limit for IRAs is $5,500; $6,500 for individuals age 50 or older. And of course, an
IRA rollover shields you from the taxes and penalties associated with a direct payout. With a rollover IRA,
you don’t pay taxes until you begin withdrawing money.
Once you’ve completed the rollover to the IRA account, it’s important to familiarize yourself with
its characteristics. With a traditional IRA, there is no earned income ceiling for eligibility to contribute.
Any future contributions may be tax deductible, depending on whether you’re an active participant in
an employer-sponsored retirement plan; if you decide to enroll in your new employer’s plan, doing so
may affect your ability to deduct future IRA contributions. IRAs are typically assessed an annual
custodial fee. Stifel IRAs are subject to a $40 per year custodial fee; $30 if multiple accounts are held
in a household.
Both employer-sponsored retirement plans and IRAs allow penalty-free withdrawals after age 59 ½.
With employer-sponsored plans, however, that age drops to 55 for individuals separated from service
with the sponsoring employer during the year in which or after reaching age 55. So, if you’re between
the ages of 55 and 59 ½, you may wish to keep your money in your employer-sponsored plan in order
to avoid having to pay a 10 percent premature distribution penalty.
If you plan on working into your 70s, you’ll want to carefully consider your options. Once you reach
age 70 ½, you must begin taking required minimum distributions from your IRA, regardless of whether
pg_0003
you’re still working or have retired. You also will no
longer be allowed to make additional contributions
to your account. With an employer-sponsored plan,
however, you typically will not be required to take
minimum distributions until retirement if you’re still
working at age 70 ½, and you can continue to make
contributions.
If you qualify, you may find that a Roth IRA is
better for your personal situation. With the Roth
IRA, contributions to the plan are not deductible,
but distributions can be withdrawn tax-free under
certain conditions. Roth IRAs also do not have
required minimum distributions while the account owner is alive. Should you decide to convert from
a plan or IRA to a Roth IRA, ordinary income tax is due on the amount converted in the year of conversion.
For some, especially younger investors, paying the tax up front can result in significant tax savings later.
Avoid Tax Withholding in a Rollover
The key to avoiding the 20 percent withholding tax is arranging a direct rollover, also known as a
“trustee-to-trustee" transfer. In order to perform a direct rollover, the distribution check from your previous
employer’s retirement plan must not be made payable to you, but to the custodian of the IRA account or
employer-sponsored retirement plan to which you wish to transfer the funds. If you wish to roll into a Stifel
IRA, your Financial Advisor can provide you with specific instructions for the check.
To initiate a rollover, you must contact your former employer’s retirement plan administrator to obtain
the forms needed to elect a direct rollover and give instructions on how the distribution check should
be made out and to whom it should be sent. If you receive a check made payable to you, as opposed
to the custodian of the IRA or your new employer’s retirement plan, you will then have 60 days to
deposit it in your rollover IRA or new employer’s plan. In order to roll over 100 percent of your money,
you’ll have to make up the 20 percent withheld for taxes with money out of your own pocket. You
would then treat the 20 percent previously withheld as a tax credit toward your current year’s tax return.
The Next Step
If you’re in the process of changing jobs or retiring, your Stifel Financial Advisor can help you understand
your rollover options in greater detail and provide information so you can select the one that makes the
most sense for your particular circumstances.
Decisions to roll over or transfer retirement plan or IRA assets should be made with careful consideration of the advantages
and disadvantages, including investment options and ser vices, fees and expenses, withdrawal options, required minimum
distributions, tax treatment, and your unique financial needs and retirement planning. Stifel does not offer tax advice. You
should consult with your tax advisor regarding your particular situation as it pertains to tax matters.
pg_0004
Stifel